Why Getting Women to Deliver in Health Facilities May Be Harder Than We Think


Every day 800 women die from preventable causes during pregnancy and childbirth. That is 292,000 women too many each year. One of the ways in which this statistic can be reduced is by simply encouraging women in low- and middle-income countries to deliver in health facilities with skilled health workers. That sounds simple enough, but it has been challenging. The number of midwives in most sub-Saharan countries, for example, desperately needs to be scaled up and in some cases health facilities and hospitals are too far for women who live in the deepest rural areas to reach. In these cases many women still prefer delivering at home which, of course, poses untold dangers to her life and the life of her baby.

But there is an underlying factor that many don’t address nearly enough that perpetually forces women to choose delivery at home over a health facility: the harsh treatment they receive from nurses and midwives at the health facilities.

It has been documented time and again that African health workers in particular can be bluntly unsympathetic and insensitive to women who are in labor and delivery. Just listen to the health worker in this mini-documentary, Birth is a Dream. At 5:00 you hear a woman crying uncontrollably during delivery and then you hear the female health worker tell her harshly, “Excuse me, there is nothing to cry like that as if they are beating you. Will you relax? Let the midwife do what’s she’s supposed to do!”

This, I am sure, happens every day and frankly, who wants to be treated in this manner? I would deliver at home, too! The problem is so bad that the White Ribbon Alliance for Safe Motherhood led the charge on drawing up Universal Rights of Childbearing Women.

An article published this week in Nigeria’s Daily Post, Why Pregnant Women Prefer Delivering at Home in Kaduna, tackles this issue.  

One of the pregnant women at the hospital who pleaded anonymity said that attitude of nurses sometimes scare women away from coming to deliver at the hospital.

Also

According to a mother of three in Kaduna who does not want her name mentioned when she was in labour at one of the government hospitals, instead of pampering and encouraging her to be patient and optimistic as a first timer, some of the nurses rained all sort of abuses on her and one of them slapped her and this discouraged her from going to the hospital for delivery.

A recent study conducted in Morogoro, Tanzania, Experiences of and responses to disrespectful maternity care and abuse during childbirth; a qualitative study with women and men in Morogoro Region, Tanzania, asked women about their birth experiences. Women recounted being shouted at for things like “wearing old or dirty clothes” or “having too many children; “ruining” one’s body” and a woman in the study recounted by slapped during delivery.

A woman was yelled at, during her delivery, for having too many children.

The nurse gets angry. She tells you, ‘You have already delivered many children. This is enough! Look at the others who have delivered only twice or thrice and stopped!’ You will (be in the middle of labor) and hear the nurse saying ‘Come and stop having children!’

– Woman, Ulanga District

With a wide range of interventions designed to encourage more mothers to deliver in health facilities it is also incumbent upon governments, global health experts, the private sector, NGOs, and health workers themselves to change the attitude some unjustly express toward women who are giving birth. Having a baby should be a joyous occassion, not one steeped in unnecessary verbal and sometimes physical abuse on top of the health challenges of giving birth in low resource settings.

There are several reasons a woman may stay home and deliver her baby even when the chances are higher that she might die. The cost of delivery may be too high. It may be for cultural reasons. She may not have the requisite items to take to a health facility. The health facility may simply be too far. But being afraid of abuse from a nurse or midwife shouldn’t be one of them.

 

6 thoughts on “Why Getting Women to Deliver in Health Facilities May Be Harder Than We Think”

  1. I totally agreew ith this analysis. As a nurse/midwife turned health administrator and nurse trainer, I am appalled at the non sympathetic attitude of colleagues in NIgeria.
    I am trying to train nurses on customer service and putting the needs of patient/client first. Basically I am trying to change this unwarranted attitude to a patient focused care attitude.
    Who wants to go to a place where you are not treated with respect or dignity? No one.
    Since moving to Nigeria fromt he states my research has shown that lack of continuous customer services within the health sector contributes to the lack of sympathy from health care workers.
    Hopefully this will change soon.
    When a pregnant woman feels secure and cared for at the ante natal clinic she will listen and practice all the healthy advice given to her by the midwife and this will ensure a safe delivery and care of hersel and her baby.

    Like

  2. Jennifer, thank you for writing this! Jacaranda Health runs maternity hospitals in per-urban regions outside of Nairobi, Kenya. And in these areas, around the city, the issue is not lack of facilities or too few maternal health providers. In order to improve maternal health and newborn health outcomes, the challenge is improving the *quality* of care provided by doctors, nurses and midwives. Most women report some type of abuse or harassment when birthing in a facility; even if it’s free (and in Kenya, the government will now provide free maternal health care to most women through NHIF). Jacaranda, then, aims to provide respectful, patient-centered, kind and high-quality care during pregnancy and childbirth. But, also, to replicate this model of care to government hospitals and private facilities throughout Kenya and then throughout East Africa. It’s only then that we’ll see truly improved health outcomes. Women not only deserve care, they deserve respectful, patient-centered, high-quality care.

    Like

    1. Thank you, Amie! It is always great to see there are NGOs making a considerable difference in the lives of women who are expecting. It is about their right to have a dignified birth. Happy to hear that Jacaranda Health is leading this charge in Kenya!

      Like

  3. Great to expose this whole other side of the issue regarding the tradition of women birthing at home. As we saw in Ethiopia to get women to birth in health care facilities is much more complex than just a build the facilities and they will come approach. In many cases women are already going outside of their cultural born to use the health care system when they give birth and his side of the story is one that is not brought up as often as some of the other challenges that might keep others away. Great post.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s